The Hidden Cost of Avoiding Tough Conversations, and How to Stop Paying It

September 2, 2025

In today’s workplace, managers are carrying more than ever before, stretching from their growing to do list, compliance, team culture, customer satisfaction, and staff retention. And often, the very tool that could bring relief, meaningful, human conversations, is the first thing to fall away.

The Hidden Costs of Avoidance

Skipping 1:1s or avoiding difficult conversations can seem like a way to gain back time, but it usually leads to a cycle of performance issues, frustration, and in some cases, diminished relationships and conflict, resulting in turnover, and more work.

According to Crucial Conversations research, and what I’ve seen play out in businesses, unresolved issues can cost companies more than $25,000 per instance. However, Gallup research confirms that just one meaningful conversation per week with each team member drives higher performance than any other leadership activity.

Why It’s Not the Manager’s Fault

Most managers aren’t avoiding conversations because they don’t care, they’re avoiding them because they were never taught how to have them. Many were promoted for technical skills, or target accomplishment, not people leadership. Without clear frameworks and help to implement them in a relational way, even well-intentioned leaders end up stuck, paying a high price, from sub-par wellness to impacts on their bottom line.

What the Brain Tells Us About Tough Conversations

From a neuroscience perspective, the brain is wired to avoid discomfort. When a difficult conversation feels like a threat, the amygdala activates the fight, flight or freeze response. Strategies grounded in how the brain works help leaders understand this. It’s about keeping your people in a safe state, open, engaged, solution and action oriented.

Mastering EQ skills like Navigating Emotions, Optimism, and balancing Consequential Thinking gives managers the insights and resilience to lead others effectively. Techniques like labeling emotions, asking open questions, and holding space help shift conversations from defensiveness to solutions.

How We Help

At People Alignment, we blend neuroscience, EQ, HR know-how and must haves, with over a decade of ICF-credentialed coaching expertise to ensure the best possible conversation outcomes. We walk you through how to apply tools that help you shift behaviours and unlock higher performance. Our approach is strategic, and grounded in what actually works across sectors and seniority levels.

Managers don’t need to start from scratch when it comes to mastering effective conversations. We equip you with simple, high-impact tools you can put into practice immediately, like:

  • pre-conversation reflection prompts to help you think through the message, the outcome, and your mindset before stepping in
  • easy to remember and highly validated coaching models so you can plan, guide and fast track the best possible conversation outcomes
  • guidance on common HR pitfalls to avoid

You don’t have to dread your next 1:1. You need a roadmap so difficult conversations become vehicles for full understanding and growth, for you and your team.

If you’re ready to lead with more ease and confidence, even in tough conversations, get in touch to explore our approach that will elevate you.